Microsoft Dynamics AX vs SAP ERP comparison

Cancel
You must select at least 2 products to compare!
Microsoft Logo
6,706 views|5,319 comparisons
SAP Logo
21,994 views|19,694 comparisons
Comparison Buyer's Guide
Executive Summary
Updated on Nov 13, 2022

We performed a comparison between Microsoft Dynamics AX and SAP ERP based on our users’ reviews in five categories. After reading all of the collected data, you can find our conclusion below.

  • Ease of Deployment: Users of both products give mixed reviews regarding the ease of their deployment.
  • Features: Users of both products are happy with their stability and scalability.

    Users of Microsoft Dynamics AX like the solution’s UI functionality, flexibility, and ease of use. Reviewers mention the database backup is slow sometimes, the reporting needs improvement, and that overall the solution needs to be simplified.

    SAP ERP users like the solution’s ability to integrate with other SAP functionalities, its control and governance software, and its high level of scalability. Reviewers of SAP ERP say the user interface is clumsy and complicated to use.
  • Pricing: Microsoft Dynamics AX users share varied opinions on the product’s pricing. Some feel it is reasonable while others feel it is costly. SAP ERP reviewers say the solution is expensive.
  • Service and Support: Users of both solutions express mixed views regarding the level of support.
  • ROI: Microsoft Dynamics AX users report a positive ROI. SAP ERP users do not mention ROI.

Comparison Results: In this comparison, users of both solutions share mixed opinions on deployment and support. The major difference between the two products is that Microsoft Dynamics AX users find the interface to be very functional, whereas SAP ERP users feel that the ERPs UI is complicated and frustrating. In addition, SAP ERP users agree across the board that it is an expensive product.

To learn more, read our detailed Microsoft Dynamics AX vs. SAP ERP Report (Updated: March 2024).
765,234 professionals have used our research since 2012.
Featured Review
Quotes From Members
We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use.
Here are some excerpts of what they said:
Pros
"In terms of features, GP offers a wide range of strong capabilities, particularly in the financial module.""This solution's most valuable feature is its workflow for purchase orders and inventory.""Technical support is very good.""The most valuable feature for us is the manufacturing module. It addresses our product costing for tuna canning.""The product's most valuable features are its day-to-day operations, Power BI-driven workspaces, and homepage.""There's a moderate amount of scalability available.""I am impressed with the tool's vendor collaboration. It is also easy to connect with third-party applications.""The most valuable features of Microsoft Dynamics AX are ease of use and performance."

More Microsoft Dynamics AX Pros →

"The product connects to every software.""Good customization features.""The solution provides a high level of integration.""The new Visual Enterprise functionalities give an intuitive approach to data and make communication between engineering and production easy.""It provides great visibility into the details of enterprise resource planning.""ERP is stable. The outcome is clear to us as far as the design goes.""We like that we have real-time dashboard views.""SAP has provided a much more integrated platform for managing our manufacturing business."

More SAP ERP Pros →

Cons
"It could be more scalable and stable. It would also be better if the interface were more integrated with the Microsoft ecosystem because 2012 is not really integrated.""The user interface could be better.""We do not have access to daily projections.""The product is standardised across industries so it is not a good fit for all types of sectors.""Microsoft Dynamics AX should include more connectors for third-party integrations. It should also include more features that AI models can govern.""Our version has performance issues so it gets stuck and is slow.""Microsoft Dynamics AX can improve system performance and security. The security is basic and needs a lot of improvement.""Change management could be better."

More Microsoft Dynamics AX Cons →

"Lacks sufficient technical support with slow response times.""I always prefer using an S/4HANA system.""It is a little difficult to use.""The warehouse management could be better.""It should be less complex. It should also have better integration capability. I am using the ACC version, and in this version, the integration and the communication are very difficult and complicated.""More integrations and built-in integrations with other environments and products are needed.""They need to improve a few processes, including transformation, intelligence, governance, modeling, etc.""I believe there's room for improvement in terms of user experience."

More SAP ERP Cons →

Pricing and Cost Advice
  • "Go for cloud implementation, if cost is critical."
  • "One client was looking at a $5M SAP proposal and we got AX in just under $2M, and they were very happy with it as they have several sister companies that face $500K SAP upgrades/maintenance seemingly annually."
  • "The pricing is expensive."
  • "It's too expensive for customers to take this on themselves. As partners, we will buy this on behalf of the customers and then charge this value for each project."
  • "It is $180 to $200 per user per month with a minimum of 20 users, which makes selling the product a bit difficult."
  • "I don't know how much this solution costs off the top of my head, but I know that the cloud and SaaS solutions are cheaper."
  • "It has a pay-as-you-go subscription."
  • "The initial investment cost goes up due to the hidden cost."
  • More Microsoft Dynamics AX Pricing and Cost Advice →

  • "SAP ECC is not cheap but I consider it the best system for managing an organization's data and processes."
  • "This is a costly product."
  • "There are licensing costs."
  • "Some components are available at an additional cost, depending on the type of contract that you have."
  • "The licensing costs are slightly on the higher side. They need to make it more competitive."
  • "SAP is a bit on the costly side, but they also provide support and other things. We are paying for licenses and the use of the cloud."
  • "SAP ERP is expensive."
  • "When you have a solution that is stable, reliable, and has a high performance as this solution, the price is going to be expensive. However, when you evaluate the service you are paying for the cost is quite reasonable for this solution."
  • More SAP ERP Pricing and Cost Advice →

    report
    Use our free recommendation engine to learn which ERP solutions are best for your needs.
    765,234 professionals have used our research since 2012.
    Comparison Review
    Anonymous User
    We put together an ERP evaluation for 3 proposed solutions. The top 3 packages considered for detailed evaluation – SAP All in One, Oracle E-Business Suite, Microsoft Axapta. The Key Criteria used for Evaluation are as follows: A. Functional Fit to meet current Business Requirements B. Flexibility to support Future Enhancements C. Project Implementation and Support Functional Fit to meet current Business Requirements: Bill of Material: Available for all three solutions.  Utility tracking - all available except for Period end allocation to batches during month's end which is unavailable for both Oracle and Axapta.  Integration of different modules - Unavailable for Oracle. Cost Accounting/Drill down capabilities of reports - Not available for Oracle.  Language compatibility - available in all three solutions.  Production reporting, in terms of operation-wise reporting, is available in all three solutions. Reorder level planning/Generates Orders based on Re-order level and Safety Stock - available for all three solutions.  Flexibility to support Future Enhancements Organization Structure: Regional cum Product line based matrix organization/Financial data capture along product line and geography based organisational structure - available for all three solutions. For Specialized Customer Orders and Expiry Date based Goods Issue - functionality not available for Axapata. Interface of PLC with ERP through middleware is available for all three of the solutions.  Project… Read more →
    Answers from the Community
    Vincenzo Catalano
    Roland Zuurveld - PeerSpot reviewerRoland Zuurveld
    Real User

    For starters, I would stop comparing tools, and start looking at my business and what I want to achieve. So identify objectives and what's blocking achievement, define quality outcomes  for the obejctives you want to achieve and build your businesscase on efficiency improvement. What earnings, savings, benefits are achieved when meeting your obectives.
    Based on the blocking issues you identified, build use cases and challenge vendors to prove their outcome by building a PoV (Proof of Value). 
    Basically start looking for what improvement your business and processes need, rather than start looking for a tool. After all a tool is just a tool.

    Gene Hammons - PeerSpot reviewerGene Hammons
    Real User

    As a followup, I would not 'assume world class ERP has these features covered'. 


    We've seen several actual cases of RFP's (which is why we no longer rely on this outdated capital procurement process to evaluate strategic deployments) - but we've seen where several vendors will check YES to the RFP question concerning a certain feature. Company A does the certain feature well, with a single click. A couple other vendors do it OK, and a couple of the YES answerers require everyone to log out of the system, balance the outlying modules, jump through 6 undecipherable processes, and then YES - it does that. 


    If that particular feature is something you need 15 or 20 times a day, well, you're probably starting an expensive and long running development effort if you picked the wrong ERP. 


    The main point is, ERP evaluations need to be a defined process by which you don't make assumptions, skip steps, and your methodology should be repeatedly proven across multiple instances, industries, and shown to deliver with different internal teams (who's mileage may vary). 


    ERP has the potential to be wildly successful and given a solid business case, provide the tools for your staff to create substantial returns. It also has the potential for abject failure, and that potential for failure is north of 80%, industrywide. So your choices are whether you are comfortable with a big pile of money or a large vat of risk. 


    Only you can determine your comfort zone. 


    Okay Akdeniz - PeerSpot reviewerOkay Akdeniz
    Real User

    1. Your business is well defined?


    SAP ERP = Company has to organize my directions. Microsoft ERP = I have to organize the company's directions. 


    2.Which industry do you stay in? In the SAP is more suitable for "Manufacturing", ERP is more suitable for "Retail and Distribution". The rest of the industries are the same difference.


    3. Your business logics are too complicated? Microsoft Dynamics can be adapted easily.


    4. On-Premise vs Cloud? On-Premise = SAP, Cloud = Microsoft


    5. Reporting? It's too hard to access Microsoft Data today. Because no one can be accessed the operational data directly.



    6. Commerce? Microsoft Commerce platform is well defined for omnichannel commerce.



    I think.


    Daniel Robus - PeerSpot reviewerDaniel Robus
    Real User

    Do you want to do it for a specific purpose or to tick a box? 


    Lets assume you are looking for system deployment. I would focus on the key areas of your business rather than what Gene has listed below, which is looking at point for point comparisons. (The Panorama report is SUPERB for getting up to speed....)


    Then look at weighting for specific key business differentiation opportunities - such as single global instance for multiple companies, integrated CRM into Finance and Operations, off-line capabilities for customer facing processes, seamless transfer of customer conversations from one channel to another.


    Then ask for client references to answer 5 key questions:


    - Are they live?


    - how was the deployment support from the OEM/partner and what was the % work split required to go live (as in your input vs partner vs OEM)


    - how many customisations were requried to achieve xxx (your key areas)


    - would they use the OEM again and what would they change going forward


    Then look at demonstration from the OEM and costing for the solution




    I would not go on a tender for each and every feature and function because we assume world class solutions have these typical areas covered.



    Happy to discuss how to do this practically if required. Daniel@liferocksconsulting.co.za

    Gene Hammons, MBA - PeerSpot reviewerGene Hammons, MBA
    MSP

    I think Panorama Consulting Group publishes some of their ERP shootouts comparing SAP/Oracle/Microsoft with Infor thrown in as a bonus. 


    Our firm is more of a boutique operation that compares internal company requirements then picks software known for its propensity to work well in those industries/environments. But if you get to the stage where you need some guidance on who some of the top partners and resources are for those software packages, hit us up. 

    Questions from the Community
    Top Answer:The product's most valuable features are its day-to-day operations, Power BI-driven workspaces, and homepage.
    Top Answer:Managing admin is difficult. Also, it is expensive and can be cheaper.
    Top Answer:We use the solution for automation. We use different modules, like, payroll, protection, sales, and getting supply chain. We're using it to streamline our resources from the start of the supply chain… more »
    Top Answer:There are different aspects of both Anaplan and SAP ERP that I like and dislike. Anaplan improves forecast accuracy and drives up the quality of analytics. Rather than spending all of their time… more »
    Top Answer:The most valuable features of SAP ERP are its stability, industry-specific package, and adaptable configuration.
    Top Answer:One challenge we face with SAP ERP is the push to upgrade to S/4HANA, which comes with significant costs. While SAP encourages this transition, we need to carefully evaluate factors like our team's… more »
    Ranking
    7th
    out of 66 in ERP
    Views
    6,706
    Comparisons
    5,319
    Reviews
    25
    Average Words per Review
    424
    Rating
    7.5
    1st
    out of 66 in ERP
    Views
    21,994
    Comparisons
    19,694
    Reviews
    36
    Average Words per Review
    433
    Rating
    8.4
    Comparisons
    Also Known As
    Dynamics AX, Axapta, MS Dynamics AX
    Learn More
    Overview

    Microsoft Dynamics AX is an enterprise resource planning (ERP) solution designed to support the business processes of organizations in a wide range of industries, including manufacturing, retail, and professional services. The solution offers a comprehensive set of tools and features to support financial management, supply chain management, human resources management, and project management, among others.

    With Dynamics AX, organizations can manage their financial operations, including general ledger, accounts payable, accounts receivable, and cash management. It also offers tools for managing the supply chain, including inventory management, purchase order management, and sales order management. Dynamics AX also supports human resources management, including employee self-service, benefits administration, and payroll. Overall, it is a flexible and scalable platform for organizations of all sizes.

    Microsoft Dynamics AX Features

    Microsoft Dynamics AX has many valuable key features. Some of the most useful ones include:

    • Financial management: Microsoft Dynamics AX offers tools for managing financial operations, including general ledger, accounts payable, accounts receivable, and cash management.
    • Supply chain management: It supports the management of supply chain operations, including inventory management, purchase order management, and sales order management.
    • Human resources management: The human resources management feature includes tools for managing human resources operations, including employee self-service, benefits administration, and payroll.
    • Project management: Microsoft Dynamics AX has tools for managing projects, including project tracking, project billing, and resource management.
    • Manufacturing: The solution supports the management of manufacturing operations, including product configuration, production planning, and quality management.
    • Retail: Microsoft Dynamics AX offers tools for managing retail operations, including point of sale (POS), merchandising, and customer management.
    • Professional services: The solution’s professional services include project management, time and expense tracking, and billing.
    • Reporting and analytics: With Microsoft Dynamics AX, business intelligence and reporting capabilities help organizations gain insight into their operations and make data-driven decisions.


    Microsoft Dynamics AX Benefits

    There are many benefits to implementing Microsoft Dynamics AX. Some of the biggest advantages the solution offers include:

    • Comprehensive: Microsoft Dynamics AX integrates with other Microsoft solutions, such as Office 365 and Power Platform, to provide a comprehensive and integrated solution for business management.
    • Streamlined operations: The solution helps organizations streamline and automate their financial, supply chain, and human resources operations, improving efficiency and reducing manual effort.
    • Customization: Microsoft Dynamics AX is a highly customizable solution that can be tailored to meet the specific needs of a wide range of industries and organizations.

    Reviews from Real Users

    Microsoft Dynamics AX is a solution that stands out when compared to many of its competitors. Some of its major advantages are its UI functionality, flexibility, and cost-effectiveness.

    "The most valuable feature I've found is the UI functionality,” says Navnath B., Head IT and CIO at Mutual Automotive Pvt Ltd.

    Another PeerSpot reviewer, Timpa A., IT Manager at an energy/utilities company says he like the solution because "It is flexible and cost-effective."

    Shahzad I., ERP Project Manager & Managing Consultant at Liwa Education, Iranfava, explains, “It's good for retail businesses. It expands a lot and constantly brings on new features. It's got a lot of competitive features.”

    SAP ERP addresses the core business software requirements of midsize and large organizations in all industries and sectors. SAP ERP includes four individual solutions that support key areas of enterprise resource planning: human capital management, financials, operations, corporate services.
    Sample Customers
    ConQuaestor, D & H Distributing, Sunny Queen, Mesa Associates, Britax Childcare, Ibema, Arafa, Sabo S.p.A.
    B&G Manufacturing, Unilever, Life is good Inc., Joy Global Inc., City of Cape Town, Bhopal Municipal, Corporation (BMC), adidas Group, Butcher & Packer Supply Company, Franklin Valve L.P., Evoshield, Prime Meats, a Norsan Group company, EMC Corporation, Varian Medical Systems Inc., FC Bayern Mªnchen AG, AkzoNobel Chemicals B.V., T¾V Rheinland, Pacific Drilling S.A., Fire & Rescue New South Wales, University of Amsterdam, Pa_alon S.A.
    Top Industries
    REVIEWERS
    Manufacturing Company34%
    Computer Software Company14%
    Retailer9%
    Financial Services Firm9%
    VISITORS READING REVIEWS
    Computer Software Company15%
    Manufacturing Company11%
    Retailer6%
    Educational Organization6%
    REVIEWERS
    Manufacturing Company25%
    Computer Software Company10%
    Financial Services Firm8%
    Pharma/Biotech Company8%
    VISITORS READING REVIEWS
    Manufacturing Company12%
    Computer Software Company12%
    Educational Organization6%
    Retailer6%
    Company Size
    REVIEWERS
    Small Business47%
    Midsize Enterprise24%
    Large Enterprise29%
    VISITORS READING REVIEWS
    Small Business29%
    Midsize Enterprise16%
    Large Enterprise55%
    REVIEWERS
    Small Business21%
    Midsize Enterprise22%
    Large Enterprise57%
    VISITORS READING REVIEWS
    Small Business22%
    Midsize Enterprise14%
    Large Enterprise64%
    Buyer's Guide
    Microsoft Dynamics AX vs. SAP ERP
    March 2024
    Find out what your peers are saying about Microsoft Dynamics AX vs. SAP ERP and other solutions. Updated: March 2024.
    765,234 professionals have used our research since 2012.

    Microsoft Dynamics AX is ranked 7th in ERP with 51 reviews while SAP ERP is ranked 1st in ERP with 100 reviews. Microsoft Dynamics AX is rated 7.6, while SAP ERP is rated 8.2. The top reviewer of Microsoft Dynamics AX writes "A stable product that offers excellent ROI and reliable technical support". On the other hand, the top reviewer of SAP ERP writes "The amazing, robust framework with unlimited scalability earns its #1 status". Microsoft Dynamics AX is most compared with Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central, SAP S/4HANA, Oracle E-Business Suite, Microsoft Dynamics GP and Oracle Fusion Cloud ERP, whereas SAP ERP is most compared with SAP S/4HANA, Anaplan, SAP Business One, Infor M3 and Infor LN. See our Microsoft Dynamics AX vs. SAP ERP report.

    See our list of best ERP vendors.

    We monitor all ERP reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.