IBM MQ vs Software AG Optimize for Infrastructure vs TIBCO Enterprise Message Service comparison

Cancel
You must select at least 2 products to compare!
IBM Logo
1,363 views|963 comparisons
94% willing to recommend
TIBCO Logo
690 views|579 comparisons
100% willing to recommend
Comparison Buyer's Guide
Executive Summary

We performed a comparison between IBM MQ, Software AG Optimize for Infrastructure, and TIBCO Enterprise Message Service based on real PeerSpot user reviews.

Find out what your peers are saying about IBM, TIBCO, Aurea and others in Business Activity Monitoring.
To learn more, read our detailed Business Activity Monitoring Report (Updated: March 2024).
768,246 professionals have used our research since 2012.
Featured Review
Quotes From Members
We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use.
Here are some excerpts of what they said:
Pros
"The most valuable feature of IBM MQ is transaction processing.""Technical support is quite helpful.""It also has a backup queue concept and topics, features that I have not seen anywhere else. I like these features very much.""Support for JMS 2.0, because we develop solutions compatible with Java EE7.""Has helped integrate between applications, reduce rework, and costs by reusing working components of existing applications.""I haven't seen any severe issues related to it. Most of the time it's running. That is the advantage of IBM MQ.""The solution is very stable.""The MQ protocol is widely used across multiple applications and it's so simple for connectivity."

More IBM MQ Pros →

"The infrastructure monitoring features are the most valuable. The primary purpose of Software AG Optimize for Infrastructure is to automate the aspects of monitoring various infrastructure and applications. They will definitely automate an alert automatically, but a lot of such tools differ from each other on aspects of various low-level components that they can monitor."

More Software AG Optimize for Infrastructure Pros →

"It is very useful tool. It is also very easy to learn and implement.​""It allows us to achieve synchronous as well as asynchronous communication with the added advantage of making the communication reliable.""​The initial setup is straightforward and the product documentation is very good.​""The Enterprise Messaging Server will store the message and wait for other subscribers to come onto the network.""TIBCO Enterprise Message Service's most valuable features are rapid zero-code integration and its large number of adapters and plugins.""The setup was done by TIBCO. It has been stable and has a server.""We have implanted the core middleware solution for the organization using this product and it is responsible for communication between different applications.""I like TIBCO's ability to create versioned queues and persistent messages."

More TIBCO Enterprise Message Service Pros →

Cons
"There could be a better front-end GUI interface for us, where we can see things more easily.""Presenting and maybe having some different options for different user experiences based on the administrative duties that you have to do as an app manager or configure the server or security would be an improvement.""With IBM products, there's less marketing. If they do more demos and more seminars on their products, it will be very useful. On a given day. I get seminar invites for many vendors and products, but for IBM, I may get an invite once or twice a year.""The clustering capabilities have provided some difficulties when it comes to resiliency. This has been a challenge for managing the environment.""It would be an advantage if they can include streaming in IBM MQ, similar to Kafka. Kafka is used mainly for streaming purposes. This feature is clearly lacking in IBM MQ. If they add this feature to IBM MQ, it will have an edge over other products.""It needs a User Interface which is better than the aging MQ Explorer. The existing solution MQ Explorer is outdated.""I can't say pricing is good.""Scaling is difficult with IBM MQ."

More IBM MQ Cons →

"Sometimes Software AG Optimize for Infrastructure goes through an upgrade cycle of four years to get to the next version. Some of the utilities need to be definitely advanced as well so that migration to the latest version is even smoother and easier. That could probably be the only improvements that they can look at. I definitely think that their cloud version capabilities are still nascent. They need to evolve into offering similar capabilities to the cloud infrastructure as well. That is not specifically SaaS but any managed infrastructure that customers would subscribe to in AWS, Azure, and other public clouds. How to employ Software AG Optimize for Infrastructure and also to see if it can be subscribed as a service from Software AG would be the ideal next steps for this solution to evolve into."

More Software AG Optimize for Infrastructure Cons →

"​Since all the communications goes through this product, it acts as a single point of failure.""An area for improvement would be integration with the API layer.""Overall, my experience with the support team has been disappointing.""TIBCO also has its proprietary line of cloud-based applications, but specifically, these two products are not cloud compatible.""I would like to see better integration with Java and Apache Kafka."

More TIBCO Enterprise Message Service Cons →

Pricing and Cost Advice
  • "It's super expensive, so ask them if they can consolidate some other licensing costs. But, IBM is IBM, so I guess we'll pay for it."
  • "IBM MQ has a flexible license model based on the Processor Value Unit (PVU) and I recommend it."
  • "Use the new and lightweight version (Liberty) to lower licensing costs. It is also easier to upgrade/maintain."
  • "I think the pricing is reasonable, especially with IIB as a part of it."
  • "Pricing could be better, as with all IBM products. But their performance in production, along with security and scalability, will pay returns in the long run."
  • "99.999 percent availability for less than a penny per message over the past 25 years. IBM MQ is the cheapest software in the IBM software portfolio, and it is one of the best."
  • "IBM MQ appliance has pricing options, but they are costly."
  • "In terms of cost, IBM MQ is slightly on the higher side."
  • More IBM MQ Pricing and Cost Advice →

    Information Not Available
  • "​The cost of licensing is very high. One should go for the product only if they need to ensure message reliability and they cannot afford to lose messages.​"
  • "In our case, we didn't pay for each product separately. We simply paid for all those companies that provided the components."
  • More TIBCO Enterprise Message Service Pricing and Cost Advice →

    report
    Use our free recommendation engine to learn which Business Activity Monitoring solutions are best for your needs.
    768,246 professionals have used our research since 2012.
    Questions from the Community
    Top Answer:Hi As someone with 45+ years of experience in the Transaction and Message Processing world, I have seen many "MQ"… more »
    Top Answer:Apache Kafka is open source and can be used for free. It has very good log management and has a way to store the data… more »
    Top Answer:IBM MQ has a great reputation behind it, and this solution is very robust with great stability. It is easy to use… more »
    Ask a question

    Earn 20 points

    Top Answer:The setup was done by TIBCO. It has been stable and has a server.
    Top Answer:Maybe the capability to undergo training for specific functionalities, such as implementing Kaspersky for handling high… more »
    Top Answer:I use TIBCO Enterprise Message Service for some of my internal communications. For instance, if there is an API called A… more »
    Ranking
    Views
    1,363
    Comparisons
    963
    Reviews
    19
    Average Words per Review
    438
    Rating
    8.6
    Views
    57
    Comparisons
    11
    Reviews
    0
    Average Words per Review
    0
    Rating
    N/A
    Views
    690
    Comparisons
    579
    Reviews
    3
    Average Words per Review
    515
    Rating
    8.0
    Comparisons
    Also Known As
    WebSphere MQ
    webMethods Optimize for Infrastructure
    Enterprise Message Service
    Learn More
    Overview

      IBM MQ is a middleware product used to send or exchange messages across multiple platforms, including applications, systems, files, and services via MQs (messaging queues). This solution helps simplify the creation of business applications, and also makes them easier to maintain. IBM MQ is security-rich, has high performance, and provides a universal messaging backbone with robust connectivity. In addition, it also integrates easily with existing IT assets by using an SOA (service oriented architecture).

      IBM MQ can be deployed:

      • On-premises
      • In the cloud
      • Hybrid cloud

      IBM MQ supports the following APIs:

      • MQI (Message Queue Interface)
      • REST
      • .NET
      • MQTT
      • JMS
      • IBM MQ Light


      IBM MQ Features

      Some of the most powerful IBM MQ features include:

      • High availability
      • Stability and scalability
      • Flexible deployment options
      • Uniform clusters
      • Automated and intelligent workload balancing
      • Broad language, API, and messaging protocol support
      • Administrative features that simplify messaging management
      • Open standards development tools
      • Simple management tools

      IBM MQ Benefits

      Some of the benefits of using IBM MQ include:

      • Multi-style messaging: IBM MQ supports simple multi-style messaging, making it easy to connect diverse systems with support for message queuing, transactions, and more.

      • Reduced risk: With IBM MQ you will never lose a message, and messages are never delivered more than once.

      • Cloud-native: Because IBM MQ has a minimal infrastructure, it is suitable to be cloud-native, and therefore has the capability to always remain on.

      • Available anywhere: Using IBM MQ, you have access to secure messaging anywhere, at any time.

      • Secure: IBM MQ makes sure to keep your data safe by using TLS secured communications, providing access identity management, message-level security, and more measures to protect your information.

      • Easy for application programmers: To use IBM MQ, application programmers do not need to have any knowledge of communications programming.

      • Technical support: IBM MQ has a large user community and also provides support 24/7 as needed.

      Reviews from Real Users

      Below are some reviews and helpful feedback written by IBM MQ users who are currently using the solution.

      PeerSpot user Sunil S., a manager at a financial services firm, explains that they never lose messages are never lost in transit, mentioning that he can store messages and forward them as required: "Whenever payments are happening, such as incoming payments to the bank, we need to notify the customer. With MQ we can actually do that asynchronously. We don't want to notify the customer for each and every payment but, rather, more like once a day. That kind of thing can be enabled with the help of MQ."

      Another PeerSpot reviewer, Luis L. who is a solutions director at Thesys Technologies, says that IBM MQ is a valuable solution and is "A stable and reliable software that offers good integration between different systems."

      The head of operations at a financial services firm notes that "I have found the solution to be very robust. It has a strong reputation, is easy to use, simple to configure in our enterprise software, and supports all the protocols that we use."

      In addition, a Software Engineer at a financial services firm praises the security benefits of it and states that “it has the most security features I've seen in a communication solution. Security is the most important thing for our purposes."

    Optimize for Infrastructure is a Business Activity Monitoring (BAM) solution that gives you real-time insight into the performance of webMethods Integration Server and Universal Messaging—the servers they run on and the applications they’re hosting. You can:

    • Optimize performance with precise, up-to-the-minute infrastructure visibility.
    • Prevent costly business disruptions with proactive alerts highlighting potential system problems before they occur.
    • Reduce the “noise” and focus on the real issues via intelligent self-learning.
    TIBCO Enterprise Message Service is a standards-based messaging solution that can serve as the backbone of an SOA by providing Java Message Service (JMS) compliant communications across a wide range of platforms and application technologies.
    Sample Customers
    Deutsche Bahn, Bon-Ton, WestJet, ARBURG, Northern Territory Government, Tata Steel Europe, Sharp Corporation
    Swisscom
    BNL, SunGard, TUI Group, UTi Worldwide, Yellow Pages Group
    Top Industries
    REVIEWERS
    Financial Services Firm39%
    Retailer10%
    Insurance Company9%
    Computer Software Company6%
    VISITORS READING REVIEWS
    Financial Services Firm37%
    Computer Software Company13%
    Manufacturing Company6%
    Government5%
    No Data Available
    VISITORS READING REVIEWS
    Financial Services Firm45%
    Computer Software Company10%
    Transportation Company5%
    Retailer5%
    Company Size
    REVIEWERS
    Small Business9%
    Midsize Enterprise9%
    Large Enterprise82%
    VISITORS READING REVIEWS
    Small Business15%
    Midsize Enterprise10%
    Large Enterprise75%
    No Data Available
    VISITORS READING REVIEWS
    Small Business8%
    Midsize Enterprise10%
    Large Enterprise82%
    Buyer's Guide
    Business Activity Monitoring
    March 2024
    Find out what your peers are saying about IBM, TIBCO, Aurea and others in Business Activity Monitoring. Updated: March 2024.
    768,246 professionals have used our research since 2012.