pfSense Review
Unfortunately, my experience with pfSense hasn’t been so good. Operational-wise it's fine but I've had issues with firmware upgrades.


I must be getting quite comfortable with upgrading pfSense. I just finished an upgrade from 2.2 to 2.2.1, and only midway remembered that I hadn’t done a config export and backup. Just the last upgrade exercise, I was still very paranoid about something that might go wrong. I would set aside time for the upgrade, make backups, and cross my fingers.

This should have been the way, always, that firmware, or device software, get upgraded. You just do it, and it should just work. The upgrade process should test that everything is good to go, and let you know if anything is amiss, before commencing the upgrade.

In the unlikely event that something does go wrong after starting the upgrade, there should be some automatic rollback, returning the system to its original state, leaving the user with no more than a small annoyance that the upgrade did not happen.

Unfortunately, my experience with pfSense hasn’t been so good. By and large, everything about pfSense has been good, operational-wise. It’s just that I’ve not been very lucky with the firmware upgrades.

Version 2.2.1 is a minor upgrade. There are a number of security fixes, but none terribly critical. The recent SSL FREAK vulnerability doesn’t affect version 2.2. However, there’s no reason why you should skip this version either. If you’re running pfSense, just do the upgrade. I’m beginning to have more faith in the pfSense upgrade process!

Disclosure: I am a real user, and this review is based on my own experience and opinions.

Add a Comment

Guest
Why do you like it?

Sign Up with Email