Cisco Catalyst Switches Other Solutions Considered
I was able to evaluate HP, Netgear, and Juniper switches.
View full review »PE
Phil Ernst
Chief Technology Officer at Wolff Logics
We like Meraki the best. Cisco is a good product, but we must pay for its name. I am not a fan of Juniper and UniFi. Meraki has the best user interface for ease of management, traffic management, and endpoint visibility. Meraki is the best product I have ever seen in my life. Meraki’s UI is super easy. The capabilities of virtual and ordinary stacking are good. Meraki is a far superior product.
View full review »NG
Nelson Gonzalez
Assistant Information Technology Director at City of Coral Gables
Prior to choosing this solution, I evaluated the IoT environment Antaira, Cradlepoint, and Sierra Wireless. Cisco's solution was superior.
In an enterprise environment, I have evaluated Juniper, Extreme, and HP. Cisco's solution fit my operational, budgeting, and logistic needs better.
View full review »Buyer's Guide
Cisco Catalyst Switches
April 2024
Learn what your peers think about Cisco Catalyst Switches. Get advice and tips from experienced pros sharing their opinions. Updated: April 2024.
768,578 professionals have used our research since 2012.
XS
reviewer1548180
Network Engineer at a manufacturing company with 10,001+ employees
I've used Juniper and HPE switches, and, if you were to compare them, I'd say there isn't too much of a difference. The functionality is pretty much the same.
You can also compare the solution to Luxul, which has better scalability.
View full review »MM
MinaMagdy
Senior Infrastructure Solutions Specialist at Fiber Misr
Dell EMC has a magnificent working portfolio, but customers still may not trust its durability and reliability. Most customers will choose Cisco rather than Dell EMC, even though Dell EMC has a reliable reputation and is very cost-effective. Yet, from my side as a partner and someone who works a lot with technology, I would recommend Dell EMC for customers with a smaller budget that needs a flexible and a cost-effective solution, rather than picking a small solution from Cisco. I would commit to buying a large solution from Dell EMC, then going with a reliable solution provider.
View full review »I am in the process of changing my core networking infrastructure, and I am moving into the new portfolio that is offered by Cisco. My boss regularly asks whether we can change from Cisco to another vendor to get better pricing, but I always reject this. We rely on Cisco.
When you have a homogenous network, as I do with only Cisco networking products, with no other components, then all of the features from the old platforms are available. I can use the same access procedures, regardless of whether the device is wireless, wired, or remotely accessed.
View full review »GM
Gaurang Modi
Project Manager at a wholesaler/distributor with 11-50 employees
Cisco is similar to other solutions such as D-Link. They have the same features.
RP
RiyazoddinPatel
Pre-Sales Solution Architect at CtrlS Datacenters Ltd
Aruba and Dell are offering switches, too.
View full review »Extreme Networks, Juniper Networks, Dell.
View full review »VD
reviewer1251825
Senior Network Engineer at a marketing services firm with 51-200 employees
We currently have the Catalyst 2960 and it is going end-of-life, so I am considering a replacement. They suggested replacing it with the 9200 but I'm currently comparing Cisco and Meraki devices.
In the market, some people are moving away from Cisco and using MikroTik devices because the price of Cisco products is too high. MikroTik products are cheaper and the gap in prices is too big. This is something that Cisco needs to consider.
View full review »HM
Hermann Medrano
Telecommunications Engineer at Universidad
I am currently evaluating several options for my client. Their goal is to improve the reliability and architecture of the network, to give them improved scalability and performance. They need a good switch, but the budget is small so I am searching for the most cost-economical one that suits their needs. In fact, for them, the price is essential now.
View full review »FB
reviewer1454511
Manager Customer Engineering South (Presales) at a comms service provider with 1,001-5,000 employees
Not relevant.
View full review »I was looking for the UniFi switch or access point because it was the first time I heard of it, so I was looking for feedback on it in comparison to TP-Link and Cisco.
View full review »ZP
reviewer654672
Owner & General Manager at a media company with 1-10 employees
Arista, Fiber Store, Dell, Extreme Networks
View full review »VP
Vasantharaju P
Senior Manager at a tech vendor with 11-50 employees
Another candidate would be Juniper switches.
View full review »AI
Al Faruq Ibna Nazim
Head of Technology at Computer Services Ltd.
I have used Cisco side-by-side with Dell and Maipu, and I found that Cisco is good. But if you compare Cisco's performance with these two, you will find that Dell and Maipu are not that bad. I wouldn't say that Maipu is that much of a product, but Dell is really performing well in comparison to Cisco.
Considering the performance, I really chose Dell. But when I have to consider that I'll have to move forward on the next project with certain security integrations, I have to consider Cisco. That is mostly the reason I considered Cisco. Otherwise, Dell would definitely have been the winner.
View full review »KR
reviewer930159
Senior Executive at a leisure / travel company with 201-500 employees
AA
Aws Al-Dabbagh
IT Manager at a tech vendor with 51-200 employees
Due to the wireless network upgrade, I'm considering other measures as well as Cisco. We're considering Aruba and we're considering Huawei. I'm considering switching to other vendors mainly because of the price.
JJ
NetworkEb6ab
Network Engineer at a manufacturing company with 10,001+ employees
Ten years ago we used Avaya and HPE.
View full review »AO
OSSENI Adé Adam
Senior Network Engineer & Technical Instructor at Improtech
We've looked at Meraki, among other solutions.
While we have used Meraki, it's hard to compare them to Catalyst switches. Meraki is quite good and agile. They've simplified a lot of their processes and have some features that make actions easy to do on Meraki. However, Catalyst offers much of the same features, and are possibly more feature-rich.
Meraki is very much more focused on business needs. While it may be good for their own business model, it doesn't encapsulate everything. Catalyst does a better job in that regard. It has many more features on offer. You aren't limited, although you will want to focus on a particular kind of feature list for your deployment or your integration into your environment.
Cisco happened to own Meraki solutions now.
IY
Ismail-Youssef
Product Specialist at a tech services company with 201-500 employees
I have evaluated other solutions, such as Juniper, HP, Aruba, and Fortinet switches
View full review »MK
Mikhail Kozlov
Lead Software QA / DevOps Engineer at a comms service provider
We tried many vendors including D-Link, HPE, and some cheaper vendors.
View full review »AL
reviewer1609476
Infrastructure Manager at a non-profit with 51-200 employees
I have evaluated Meraki switches which is an easier version of Cisco Catalyst Switches.
View full review »I use a lot of switches on the campus: Juniper, Extreme, etc. I use multiple vendors. However, Cisco and Juniper are my preferred vendors.
View full review »Cisco was the best and only option that I considered.
View full review »LL
Lucio Lopez
IT Consultant at L&M Alpha Solutions
For our company, Cisco's competition was Aruba.
View full review »There were no other options looked at.
View full review »HPE comes into the picture because they have a wireless product. It's a good product. We definitely propose their switches.
View full review »OP
Oswald Polo
Electronic Engineer at eBTel Cia. Ltda.
My customers have evaluated Huawei and HP.
View full review »ML
NetworkE1c8f
Network Engeneer at a retailer with 10,001+ employees
We also looked at HPE and Juniper.
View full review »AB
Akshay Balaganur
Founder and Lead Network Consultant at Airowire Networks
There are a lot of options when it comes to switching products. Brocade offers good switches, HPE offers a very affordable set of switches. But the purchase decision depends on a lot of factors. Primarily, Cisco provides an end-to-end solution, all aspects of networking, from UIP to security to wireless to servers. That factor plays into it.
View full review »We also looked at Dell options.
View full review »MB
ChiefDepbed6
Chief Deputy Quality Audit
We also looked at Huawei but we went with Cisco because we're more comfortable with them even though their prices are a little higher.
View full review »Buyer's Guide
Cisco Catalyst Switches
April 2024
Learn what your peers think about Cisco Catalyst Switches. Get advice and tips from experienced pros sharing their opinions. Updated: April 2024.
768,578 professionals have used our research since 2012.