Planview IdeaPlace vs Slack comparison

Cancel
You must select at least 2 products to compare!
Planview Logo
123 views|14 comparisons
Slack Logo
2,645 views|1,170 comparisons
Featured Review
Quotes From Members
We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use.
Here are some excerpts of what they said:
Pros
"As a global organization, we are able to allow all our associates around the world to contribute and collaborate.""The voting ability is its most valuable feature. Teammates can vote an idea up or down. They can also offer feedback, and that feedback is instantaneous. It is a tool which allows us to gauge the temperature of certain product enhancements. Our system enhancements are potential areas of gaps that we have in our business.""The biggest impact of using Planview would be that we were able to bridge the silos which existed between a lot of different departments or even locations. We have a very large team member base of about 75,000 employees across various different parts of the country. Being able to bridge that gap and have a way for everybody to communicate together to collaborate together, that was a first for our organization. That's been one of the most valuable things that we've seen. We also see those results in our organizational health survey as well. Our team members truly feel like this is a very inclusive, innovative company. That's been beneficial.""The ability to collect ideas for people to be able to comment and vote. We like the pairwise portion of it. It is just a simple way in which people can post ideas and review other ideas. We have used it out-of-the-box, without doing much customization.""The crowdsourcing feature and having an open, transparent platform where people can submit ideas are among the most important capabilities of Spigit. Collaboration begins immediately upon submission.""The most valuable feature of Spigit is the fact that we can reach so many people with crowdsourcing. We can go across departments and branches, still being engaged and doing it so quickly.""The nice thing is how flexible it is. We can run very small challenges. We can run very large challenges. We haven't had a company-wide challenge but we hope to have one this year. We can run a challenge within a day, with several features, or we can run a challenge over two months or an always-on challenge. We can have different goals, whether they be about culture, workplace improvements, business solutions, or strategic issues.""It has an "Apple" approach where, when you open it, you understand how most of the functionality and features work. With just a little bit of guidance or training, and the videos that we watched, we were up and running really quickly."

More Planview IdeaPlace Pros →

"The product has the ability to scale.""The huddle feature is valuable to me.""The feature that I have found most valuable is communication between team members.""Slack is a very collaborative tool that makes it easier for me to communicate with the onboarding and billing teams.""Slack is a collaboration tool where you can create specific topic-related channels and manage different threads on different talks so people can interact and maintain a chat.""You can create channels between teams internally and externally, which is great. There is a lot of security with Slack internal, which is what I value.""The product makes communication seamless.""The most valuable feature is that we can easily integrate different workloads and the alerts are reliable. Also because it allows us to use it as a monitoring tool sometimes."

More Slack Pros →

Cons
"Setting up a challenge timeline is a bit tedious and could be improved. in Spigit, the timeline is done with phases. You have to manually enter the start and stop of each phase. When you change one, all subsequent phases get changed automatically but are not consistent with the way you had it. There is a lot of double checking. This could be simplified to: I want this to start here and go for this many days. It would be a lot easier on the setup.""We haven't really leveraged the reports. The reports are sort of difficult and archaic, e.g., how it downloads into Excel. They are not in a usable manner where other people can look at them. I personally will look at them, but the reports are not the easiest to generate from their system.""The backend configuration could be a little bit easier to configure. It was a little bit cumbersome for a layman to understand how to design some of the functionality and programming on the backend. Although they do offer training courses to support building that skillset.""Our biggest issue would be whenever there is an update or upgrade version, there are some things that break in the links between some of the login things on the back-end. The Planview team has done a great job of trying to put together information ahead of time and having different sessions to inform us. However, there are some things that we always end up finding in the test sessions after the updates have been done. Once we get those things ironed out, it's perfectly fine until the next upgrade. We've gone through about three upgrades, and it's happened all three times. That's the biggest pain point that we've had.""There are times when some of the system aspects move a little bit slowly, but that's a pretty minor complaint. For the most part, those are things that we see behind the scenes as administrators or moderators of challenges.""I would like more of an ability to create reporting. There are dashboards in there and they are awesome. Maybe there is probably a training class or something that they should do. I went to the Spigit training, but we didn't get into the reporting side, at least not when it came to being able to build your own reports. They showed us the reporting and where it was, but there were already dashboards built into the platform. I would like to be able to go in, create my own reporting, and take out the information and data that I feel is relevant.""Spigit could possibly improve the idea review process or the administrative panel for reviewing ideas. It's not strong. Most of it is done manually by pulling down and reviewing reports. Other platforms are doing it through pipelines and funnels that are all automated.""It does enable us to consolidate duplicate responses from employees, but it is difficult sometimes. We are running a challenge right now with two ideas that are pretty close and duplicate. Once they're out there and a significant amount of people have voted on them, it's hard to consolidate or merge them. The merge feature is not very clear, so it basically hides one of the ideas, removing and archiving it. I don't know if that's the best way to do it. I would want to make the secondary idea still visible, but put it under as a possible subidea to the parent idea."

More Planview IdeaPlace Cons →

"Slack could add additional and better integrations.""The reason is we are moving towards a new CRM, so we have a suitable solution to integrate with the new CRM.""Slack feels clustered and hence it should improve its design and UI.""The only area of concern that I have is with the inability to preview received documents without having to download them first.""The tool has stability issues that need to be improved. We are not native English speakers and Slack needs to integrate grammar checks.""I think Slack could add additional features without making the solution slower or more difficult to use.""The tool should be able to fetch a conversation when we search for it even if it is in the thread.""Its capabilities to provide security features could be better for corporations."

More Slack Cons →

Pricing and Cost Advice
  • "Because the platform is used in another department, we have one parent. We are able to break off and do platforms for other business units under that parent."
  • "The yearly licensing cost is $55,000."
  • "We have a tiered annual licensing fee."
  • "Planview could drop the price for Spigit. I've done two market assessments and I think that they're overpriced pretty considerably right now."
  • More Planview IdeaPlace Pricing and Cost Advice →

  • "We use the free version that does not have a license."
  • "The solution is expensive."
  • "It is less expensive than one of its competitors."
  • "It is an expensive tool. We pay 15 to 20 USD monthly per user."
  • "Slack is definitely worth the money."
  • "The pricing can range up to about twenty bucks a user. You can spend a lot of money, especially if you're talking about thousands of users. Generally speaking, Slack is less expensive than Teams. Slack doesn't include all the bells and whistles that Teams does. So you can go from a $6 license in Microsoft 365 to a $50 license per user per month, and there's a lot more you can do in the $50 license."
  • "I would rate the tool's pricing a four out of ten."
  • "The solution is cheap in my country."
  • More Slack Pricing and Cost Advice →

    report
    Use our free recommendation engine to learn which Innovation Management Software solutions are best for your needs.
    765,234 professionals have used our research since 2012.
    Questions from the Community
    Ask a question

    Earn 20 points

    Top Answer:Channels and channel search is what I use most, in addition to common workspaces with partners.  Especially those channels where everyone can post can be so beneficial.  It is so easy like a… more »
    Top Answer:When I share any file with my colleagues, that file remains in Slack storage even after I delete the message. I need to manually delete them one by one. It would be better if Slack had a 'select all'… more »
    Ranking
    Views
    123
    Comparisons
    14
    Reviews
    0
    Average Words per Review
    0
    Rating
    N/A
    Views
    2,645
    Comparisons
    1,170
    Reviews
    32
    Average Words per Review
    353
    Rating
    8.4
    Comparisons
    SharePoint logo
    Compared 17% of the time.
    Atlassian Confluence logo
    Compared 16% of the time.
    Symphony logo
    Compared 15% of the time.
    Chatter logo
    Compared 13% of the time.
    ChatWork logo
    Compared 12% of the time.
    Also Known As
    Planview Spigit, Spigit
    Learn More
    Planview
    Video Not Available
    Overview

    Join the 6M+ employees at 500+ enterprise companies that are using Planview IdeaPlace (formerly Planview Spigit) to bring the power of collective intelligence to every business challenge.

    Slack is where work happens. It’s a digital workspace that powers your organization — all the pieces and the people — so you can get things done.

    Slack brings all your communication together in one place. It's real-time messaging, archiving and search for modern teams.

    Sample Customers
    Pfizer, UnitedHealth Group, Citi, AT&T, Cambia Health, Siemens, Veridian Credit Union, Polaris, UNHCR, CCA Global
    Strava, The New York Times, Spotify, Blue Bottle Coffee Company, Eventbrite, Box, Circa, Stripe
    Top Industries
    REVIEWERS
    Financial Services Firm25%
    Energy/Utilities Company25%
    Healthcare Company25%
    Manufacturing Company13%
    REVIEWERS
    Computer Software Company24%
    Marketing Services Firm13%
    Financial Services Firm13%
    Healthcare Company7%
    VISITORS READING REVIEWS
    Educational Organization82%
    Computer Software Company4%
    Financial Services Firm4%
    University1%
    Company Size
    REVIEWERS
    Small Business13%
    Large Enterprise88%
    REVIEWERS
    Small Business63%
    Midsize Enterprise13%
    Large Enterprise24%
    VISITORS READING REVIEWS
    Small Business5%
    Midsize Enterprise83%
    Large Enterprise12%

    Planview IdeaPlace is ranked 1st in Innovation Management Software while Slack is ranked 3rd in Enterprise Social Software with 67 reviews. Planview IdeaPlace is rated 8.6, while Slack is rated 8.4. The top reviewer of Planview IdeaPlace writes "Provides a mechanism for our leadership to understand the pulse of what's happening in our operations". On the other hand, the top reviewer of Slack writes "A competitive solution that improves collaboration and productivity". Planview IdeaPlace is most compared with , whereas Slack is most compared with SharePoint, Atlassian Confluence, Symphony, Chatter and ChatWork.

    We monitor all Innovation Management Software reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.