ArcSight Enterprise Security Manager (ESM) Other Solutions Considered
Securonix was a cheaper solution and more based on a data science foundation. It is good at handling structured data, making it an attractive option for open platform deployments.
Another is RapidX, which is an open-source platform based on the free ELK Stack, offering significant cost advantages. With some effort from our side as a Managed Service Provider, we were able to create a RapidX deployment that surpassed ArcSight in functionality.
ArcSight is a commercial, enterprise-grade solution. While it carries a higher price tag, it offers greater scalability suited for large-scale deployments.
View full review »We evaluated Curator. Curator is easier to set up than ArcSight, and it has a UI that is simpl to use.
View full review »We evaluated Splunk, QRadar, and LogRhythm.
View full review »Buyer's Guide
ArcSight Enterprise Security Manager (ESM)
March 2024
Learn what your peers think about ArcSight Enterprise Security Manager (ESM). Get advice and tips from experienced pros sharing their opinions. Updated: March 2024.
765,234 professionals have used our research since 2012.
PM
PeterMendonca
Sr. Group Manager at WNS Global Services
We looked at three other solutions. I was working for a government organization, and there was an Indian company developing its own team. ArcSight was head and shoulders above the rest in features like aggregation filtering, bandwidth, parsing, etc. It was there.
Hopefully, we're still way ahead, but the IT data architecture is getting a bit complex with the introduction of Kubernetes and everything. It will be complicated in terms of resources, deployment, etc., but I think ArcSight can still be what it used to be if we sort this out.
View full review »LogRhythm has a better GUI and some automation options, like an automated password writing script. In Exabeam, I can see an event with the user's picture, which Exabeam can draw from the Active Directory. It has a better GUI, better performance, and customization. I expect these things from ArcSight, but it can't deliver yet.
View full review »We have evaluated IBM QRadar before choosing ArcSight ESM.
View full review »Before ArcSight, we looked at QRadar and Splunk.
View full review »We have used Micro Focus ArcSight from the beginning.
View full review »This is the best SIEM solution on the market comparing to its competitors. I'm also familiar with IBM QRadar, RSA Security Analytics, McAfee Nitro, and Splunk.
View full review »
I've been looking at Open Source SIEM recently, and paying a lot of attention to the others in the commercial market, like IBM and MacAfee, but I don't have any practical experience. I have heard mixed reviews about all of them (including AS from some folks I know).
View full review »
TB
Teguh Budyantara
IT Manager at Royal Cemerlang
At the time that we were looking into options, we did a PoC for Splunk. We found that ArcSight is more user-friendly than Splunk because Splunk uses more scripting in the configuration and initial setup.
View full review »We evaluated IBM QRadar, McAfee ESM, and AlienVault.
View full review »We looked at other solutions such as Splunk and IBM QRadar.
View full review »ArcSight was chosen by my new company management without asking me for my opinion.
View full review »BS
reviewer1370811
Head - Professional Services at a computer software company with 51-200 employees
I have some experience with Splunk and Curator.
There are a few differences. Splunk, for example, is a native cloud product. That makes it excellent for scalability. Any on-premise challenges a company might face are answered by Splunk.
In both solutions, you are able to integrate and manage other devices as well, which isn't necessarily true on Arcsight.
View full review »HM
Hatem Metwally
Senior Security Consultant, CISSP, HPE ArcSight Specialist at a retailer with 5,001-10,000 employees
SW
reviewer987771
Senior Manager at a tech services company with 51-200 employees
We evaluated other solutions prior to choosing ArcSight ESM, such as Splunk and RSA NetWitness. We decided on ArcSight ESM because it was cost-effective.
View full review »We evaluated Splunk and McAfee Log Manager.
View full review »We evaluated McAfee ESM.
View full review »We also looked at Splunk and LogRhythm for every installation. All three have their own benefits. For large scale installations with multiple users and (sub) companies, ArcSight is the best option.
View full review »We are now working with open-source systems and Splunk solutions. We are decommissioning HPE ArcSight as it is getting impractical to manage and maintain the solution.
View full review »We evaluated QRadar and Splunk.
View full review »
Splunk, RSA Envision, McAfee Nitro and IBM QRadar
View full review »
LL
Ly Binh Lap
Network Security Engineer, Security Monitoring Center at a tech services company
I researched Splunk, QRadar and AlienVault, and I appreciate Splunk and ArcSight.
View full review »GS
ProductS9907
Product Specialist Security Solutions at a tech services company with 201-500 employees
As a partner, we sell the product. We shifted from RSA to ArcSight based on our internal evaluations.
We tested McAfee Nitro, which was not mature enough at the time compared to ArcSight.
View full review »We chose ArcSight when they had no real competitor and we stayed with them.
View full review »MS
reviewer1501149
Managing partner at a tech services company with 11-50 employees
At a marketing level, we've checked out Splunk. We have not tested it internally on our servers. We simply took a closer look at their marketing and their strategic messaging.
View full review »For SIEM, I think HP ArcSight is a leading competitor alongside Splunk.
View full review »
We evaluated Alien Vault.
View full review »
MJ
MuhammadJunaid3
Techniqal Lead Enterprise Solution at a tech services company with 51-200 employees
According to the Gartner Reports and Gartner Reviews, the main competitors of the solution are IBM and Splunk. They provide their services world-wide and do much implementation in the region.
the plus point for Arcsight ESM is having cross domain corelation feature.
View full review »GM
reviewer1284078
Information Security Analyst at a comms service provider with 1,001-5,000 employees
We are actually moving to another solution because the roadmap is not clear. We are just a small team and we don't need to monitor 24/7. We're looking to replace it with another more intelligent solution like Splunk or Securonix.
We looked at QRadar and LogRhythm.
View full review »Buyer's Guide
ArcSight Enterprise Security Manager (ESM)
March 2024
Learn what your peers think about ArcSight Enterprise Security Manager (ESM). Get advice and tips from experienced pros sharing their opinions. Updated: March 2024.
765,234 professionals have used our research since 2012.