PRTG Network Monitor Other Solutions Considered

Omar_Jaimes - PeerSpot reviewer
Cybersecurity Architecture Manager at Data Warden

We did not previously evaluate other solutions.

View full review »
SK
Infrastructure Engineer at Lookers plc

SolarWinds was something that we re-evaluated. We were also using ManageEngine and Zabbix.

I came on board when we were downloading an evaluation of the actual software. We were doing our due diligence across other platforms/software, and PRTG came out top. 

Part of the pilot phase was to see how much load it would have on our network, and if there would be any sort of bottlenecks. We have been pretty happy with it. It has not had any sort of flow back on us, as a business.

View full review »
SyedKareemuddin - PeerSpot reviewer
IT Manager at COCA COLA

I compared PRTG Network Monitor with SolarWinds and ManageEngine. I chose PRTG Network Monitor over other products in the market since it provides complete monitoring of my servers and network devices. SolarWinds and ManageEngine have different products for server monitoring and different products for network monitoring.

View full review »
Buyer's Guide
PRTG Network Monitor
March 2024
Learn what your peers think about PRTG Network Monitor. Get advice and tips from experienced pros sharing their opinions. Updated: March 2024.
767,847 professionals have used our research since 2012.
DC
Infrastructure Team Lead at a recreational facilities/services company with 10,001+ employees

Primarily, we use PRTG because I am familiar with it. We have licenses for SCOM, but the complexity in setting up that type of solution put us off. It is very much a big beast of a solution. We needed something quick and simple that we could just throw in and get some good figures out of it quickly.

View full review »
AG
Infrastructure Manager at a non-profit with 1,001-5,000 employees

We just considered PRTG when moving away from SolarWinds.

View full review »
Pierre-Anderson ELLO - PeerSpot reviewer
IT Manager at Cdci

Difficile de concevoir des tableaux de bord

View full review »
AW
IT Coordinator at ENGIE Renewables Ltd

I have actually used other solutions, because I do look after four domains. Previously, they had other packages that were already there, and I still find PRTG to be the best.

View full review »
CB
Senior Security Engineer at Fletchers Solicitors Ltd.

We didn't really consider anything else because we'd previously used PRTG, before we used our third-party partner. It was very easy for us to come back to it.

View full review »
MR
CEO at a tech services company with 11-50 employees

PRTG and SolarWinds both offer comprehensive solutions, but PRTG's simpler pricing model based on device count makes it more appealing. With PRTG, everything is included in one package, whereas SolarWinds often requires additional monthly payments for various features. This straightforward pricing structure makes PRTG a preferred choice for many.

View full review »
LS
Engineer at Datacentreplus

We looked at SolarWinds. If I remember correctly, it came down to cost. In that regard, PRTG did work out cheaper. In addition, one of our engineers had previously worked with PRTG so he had a bias toward PRTG already. It just made sense to go with it.

View full review »
TD
Infrastructure Manager at a logistics company with 10,001+ employees

I don't have any comparison with direct competitors. We have been using PRTG for the better part of possibly ten years now. We haven't found the feature set lacking. Everything that we have tried to do, we have managed to work with PRTG to do it.

View full review »
MahmoudMohamed - PeerSpot reviewer
Network Professional Services Team Lead at e-finance

We have evaluated a lot of software and we found PRTG Network Monitor the best solution.

View full review »
TM
Head of Customer Service - Advanced Technologies at a logistics company with 501-1,000 employees


Three years ago when we took PRTG, we had a trainee make a small inquiry and we concluded that regarding the needs we have today, PRTG was the best solution. We concluded at the time that it would be much easier to use. The technical gap between PRTG and the other solutions would not be relevant to how we planned to use it.

View full review »
CW
Systems Engineer at Converse Pharma Group

We looked at PRTG and SolarWinds. From a cost side perspective, compared to PRTG, and from what you get back from it, PRTG was sort of a hands down the winner. We had read a few different reviews of PRTG and had a few of the colleagues that we'd worked with in the past who now used it at their new businesses and recommending it. These were sort of the main driving factors for going down that route.

View full review »
PD
System & Network Lead at Beachcombers Vacations

We did not evaluate other options.

View full review »
AJ
IT Manager at SILVERSTRING LTD

I tried out a few of the free solutions, but I just couldn't get on with them. Since going with PRTG, we haven't bothered looking anywhere else because it has done whatever we've needed it to do.

View full review »
RV
ICT-Manager at Heinen & Hopman Eng BV

Although we aren't actively searching for other solutions, from time to time, we do check the market to see what else is available and compare it to this product.

View full review »
CW
IT Manager at a marketing services firm with 51-200 employees

PRTG was the only vendor on the list. I knew what I wanted and knew I could get it.

View full review »
AS
Information Security Analyst at a financial services firm with 51-200 employees

We had a look at SolarWinds, their network monitoring suite, which was the big player in the market. It's got a price tag to match and that was certainly a factor. Admittedly, it is a much bigger product, it's got broad capabilities and it's got different kinds of integrations. For what we needed at that time, PRTG absolutely suited.

View full review »
RC
Network Manager at Baldwin Family Health Care

It was recommended by our network engineers. Other clients use PRTG and have had a great experiences with it.

View full review »
JV
System Administrator at a government with 1,001-5,000 employees

SolarWinds, WhatsUp, OpenNMS, Nagios, Netcool, OPManager, Splunk

View full review »
Venkatesh Koppula - PeerSpot reviewer
Tech Specialist at a tech services company with 51-200 employees

I have compared other tools to PRTG Network Monitor. I found that PRTG Network Monitor is more user-friendly than the others I compared.

View full review »
YA
Dev Ops Engineer at a computer software company with 10,001+ employees

I evaluated Centron, which is more flexible and customizable, but I think that PRTG is easier to administer. The initial setup with PRTG is also easier than with other solutions at the same level.

View full review »
JR
CEO & Founder at SISTECO

The other product that our customers normally consider is SolarWinds.

SolarWinds is a more robust solution, and as such, it is much more expensive than PRTG. Most of the time, based on budget, our customers choose PRTG.

View full review »
GB
Network Engineer

I had previously used PRTG 

View full review »
DA
IT Infrastructure Engineer at Runshaw College

PRTG was recommended to us and we went with it on the free basis to start with and then we moved to the paid version, for more sensors. We haven't really compared it to anything else, because it was recommended. Overall it seems very good.

View full review »
it_user407175 - PeerSpot reviewer
IT Adminstrator with 501-1,000 employees

generally work with open source solutions such as Zabbix, Nagios, Cacti or Pandora FMS. In this case it could be compared to WhatsApp Gold, but I think PRTG is more useful for compact and simple environments.

View full review »
AB
Network Administrator at a construction company with 201-500 employees

We looked at SolarWinds and we looked at NetManage but went for PRTG in the end.

View full review »
JR
Senior Network Engineer at Axesat S.A.

We might be considering looking into other solutions in the future.

View full review »
it_user1062024 - PeerSpot reviewer
Infrastructure Analyst

We evaluated a number of different server monitoring solutions and selected PRTG as the best solution to go forward with. We looked at WhatsUp Gold and Nagios. PRTG was much easier to use, configure, set up, and get running. It provided better information which was very well displayed.

We also had downtime previously. That was definitely why we went ahead with a monitoring solution, so we could be alerted quickly to any issues and resolve them before they affected our service and users.

View full review »
GM
Group Information Security Manager at a comms service provider with 201-500 employees

We've had PRTG in place for a number of years, so what we evaluated was in the early days, a lot of open-source solutions: Zabbix, Nagios, Cacti, etc. PRTG is differentiated because it caters to all platforms and endpoints, has features for Windows, and WMI sensors which aren't necessarily available out-of-the-box in the other solutions. That would have been a determining factor.

View full review »
PM
Systems Specialist at a manufacturing company with 1,001-5,000 employees

We had previous experience with things like HP OpenView, but it's been many years now. Our experience with it was that it was quite sluggish, very expensive. PRTG seemed to be at a very attractive price point, and its speed and the reviews we'd seen about it were really compelling.

View full review »
AG
Network Engineer at a tech vendor with 51-200 employees

We looked at the market, and it wasn't PRTG at first, which was just something we found from recommendations from other people along with a carrier that we worked with, a partner of ours, they actually used it. That was what sort of led us to it. They were using it for their end users, showing customers PRTG data files, stating, "We can give you all this information." We were like, "We want to do that as well!" So, we sort of stole it from them. 

We are extensively using its feature set, and there are a load of features in the product that which other solutions don't have.

It is abundantly helpful in bringing all our stuff in-house. Another platfrom that we use is SolarWinds Orion, which is a pure network monitoring tool. PRTG is much more reliable, easier to use, and the information is more clear and concise.

View full review »
JB
Cloud Engineer at Software Cloud Limited

We did trial four solutions, including PRTG. Obviously, we were using Azure, and I can't remember the others. They may have been SolarWinds and Opsgenie but that wasn't really going to do it for us.

View full review »
DB
Cybersecurity Engineer at a tech services company

My technical director chose this solution out of all the products that he had a look at, as it stood out straightaway.

View full review »
it_user650931 - PeerSpot reviewer
Technical Consultant at Celerity Limited

No, PRTG had already been selected as our monitoring tool.

View full review »
PB
Security Engineer at a wellness & fitness company with 5,001-10,000 employees

We also have monitoring with SolarWinds, as well. What we find is that SolarWinds is great for reporting and delving back into logs, but PRTG is better for that instant on knowing what is going on right now.

There are quite a wide array of different sensors with PRTG. However, we are only really utilizing SNMP, Ping, and similar functions at the moment. Because our NetFlow data goes into SolarWind, we want that report inside it. We find SolarWinds better for this. Though, we know that we could do this if we wanted and put some NetFlow data into PRTG with its multiple different sensors.

We are not using the solution to its fullest capacity. At this point, I don't think we will because we are so involved with SolarWinds. We are getting out of PRTG what we want to get out of it, but we are not getting enough from it that we could ditch SolarWinds and move over to it.

View full review »
JR
Network Engineer at a financial services firm with 201-500 employees

We did look at a couple of other solutions, but partly because we had somebody with in-house knowledge of PRTG and ability in it, they essentially gave it reasonably good reviews from their personal usage. So we chose to go with something that was a known factor.

We would have looked at stuff like SolarWinds and some others, but off the top of my head, I can't remember which ones.

View full review »
it_user1422201 - PeerSpot reviewer
Network Department MAnager at Engineering Consultants Group S.A.

We are currently evaluating many other security solutions.

View full review »
it_user720498 - PeerSpot reviewer
Monitoring Specialist at a construction company with 10,001+ employees

I was not the decision maker so no comment.

View full review »
RV
Regional Head of IT at a manufacturing company with 10,001+ employees

I have evaluated SolarWinds and it is one of the easiest for beginners to start working with network monitoring.

View full review »
AK
Technical Manager

We evaluated several other solutions and one of the reasons that we chose PRTG is because they provided us with a free trial that included all of the sensors. This gives you the opportunity to test the product and see it work. After that, if you are satisfied with it, you can purchase it.

The other solutions that we tried will give you only a few sensors. You do not have the full functionality of the system available for testing.

View full review »
RP
Director - Operations at Shell Networks & Solutions Ltd

While I didn't properly evaluate SolarWinds, I have seen other people using it and I found that it had a very nice graphical grid and GUI.

View full review »
it_user865332 - PeerSpot reviewer
Engineering and Pre-Sales Manager at a tech services company with 11-50 employees

We were previously considering Nagios Core, because it is over Linux and an open source solution. However, its problem is you have to do everything from scratch.

View full review »
Buyer's Guide
PRTG Network Monitor
March 2024
Learn what your peers think about PRTG Network Monitor. Get advice and tips from experienced pros sharing their opinions. Updated: March 2024.
767,847 professionals have used our research since 2012.