We’re in the process of comparing IBM vs. CA. Which one is better?


IT Central Station is a fast-growing and trusted professional social network for users of enterprise tech solutions. Our mission is to provide professionals like you with valuable info from your peers. Use IT Central Station to exchange advice, access 2,500+ product reviews, and promote your expertise.

Anonymous avatar x30
As seen in

5 Answers

32931605 8934 49ab bd02 26517cb0d2e2 avatar?1447902544
Shailesh K.MReal User

Is there any Open Source IAM software which is recommended ?

Like (0)05 September 16
Jyoti bhattacharjee li?1414331932

I agree with both Jason and Timothy's remarks. Neither IBM nor CA is free of their legacy approach to identity management. Moreover, cross domain identity management across hybrid cloud, inter-cloud and on-site environment poses challenges that are not adequately addressed by either of these two vendors.

Like (0)16 April 14
Timothy sim li?1414332038
Timothy SimConsultant

You should probably take a step back and see what it is that you are trying to achieve with the products then decide which is best for you. In fact, you may find that neither of them is what you want in the end. Identity management is a complex beast and it can't be boiled down to a straight product choice.

Like (0)10 April 14
Anonymous avatar x30
Jason MacyReal UserTOP 20

Both companies rely on legacy acquired technologies with little new innovation on the acquired platforms. This leads to substantial professional services costs, implementation costs, and maintenance costs. Best of breed vendors pay more attention to your needs, are more innovative, and have more agility than technology aggregates such as CA and IBM.

Like (0)09 April 14
Cindy gravely li?1414331860
Cindy GravelyReal UserTOP 20

I feel that IBM is the better product due to the complexity of the components of the CA product. Troubleshooting system issues with the CA product is very difficult since there are many processes that run which are typically installed on individual servers so that the right IT team can manage and support the component of the Identity Management system. I believe the CA product requires too much reliance on Professional Services.

I'm not experienced with IBM but did work somewhere that used that product and it was all handled by one person. I'm not aware of there being a reliance on Professional Services.

I personally use the NetIQ product and feel it is very easy to use and support. I realize that one isn't one that you are evaluating, however, it is a great product.

Like (0)09 April 14
As seen in

Sign Up with Email