Which product would you choose: IBM Rational Doors vs. IBM Rational DOORS Next Generation?

Below are some of the differences between IBM Rational DOORS and IBM Rational DOORS Next Generation, which are Requirements Management tools that can be used by mechanical design and analysis engineers:

IBM Rational DOORS

Pros:

• Well-established and widely used


• Comprehensive Requirements Management capabilities


• Strong support for traceability


• Easy to use and maintain

Cons:

• Some say that setting it up and configuring it can be complex


• May not be as scalable as IBM Rational DOORS Next Generation

IBM Rational DOORS Next Generation

Pros:

• Built on a modern platform


• Reported to be more scalable and flexible than IBM Rational DOORS


• Supports agile development


• Some say the solution integrates better with other IBM products

Cons:

• May not be as well-established as IBM Rational DOORS


• Some features are still in development

The best solution for you will depend on the needs and requirements of your company or organization. If you are looking for a well-established and widely used Requirements Management tool with comprehensive capabilities, IBM Rational DOORS may be a suitable choice. However, if you want a more scalable and flexible tool that supports agile development, IBM Rational DOORS Next Generation may be the better option.

Here are additional factors to consider when picking out a Requirements Management tool:

• The size and complexity of your organization


• The type of projects you are working on


• Your budget


• Your technical expertise